left arrow BackNext right arrow
< BACK TO Fresh Intelligence

Critics: Spider-Man 3 Worst Sequel Ever

tobey_kirstien_050307_FRESH.jpg
YOU SUCK! NO, YOU SUCK! Tobey Maguire, Kirsten Dunst
With all of the money and hype surrounding Spider-Man 3, there must be a gem of a movie lurking at the bottom of Sony's tangled web. Not according to critics, whose vitriol has spiked to levels unseen since Ishtar. Below, the blurbs you'll never see on the SM3 DVD ...

The New York Observer: "Bloated and stupid, this movie is so bad you can't even review it. Over-
produced, over-publicized, over-designed, over-
computerized and just plain over the moon, it's so preposterously overwrought with so many bewildering plots juggling simultaneously for over-emphasis, there's no entry point for criticism. You just stare at it, as you might a great big exploding pile of cow manure."

The New Yorker: "In an early scene, a meteorite crashes to Earth, and from it crawls what seems to be a tiny garbage sack with half a mind of its own: not a bad image of where this film belongs."

The Village Voice: "The best that can be said of Spider-Man 3 is that it sheds some light on the whole skinny black jeans phenomenon. Rest easy Hedi Slimane and residents of the 11211, the origin of overpriced mantyhose may now be attributed to the nefarious agenda of intergalactic goo."

Dallas Observer: "It all just feels so ... Fantastic Four, so dopey and forgettable and crafted out of second-rate cheese."

UK Times Online: "This incessant Tom and Jerry action makes it impossible to actually care. The Sunday School morality, and the inevitable flash of the American flag, are perfectly irritating."

Philadelphia Weekly: "Bigger, louder, and a good deal longer than its delightful predecessors, Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 3 makes just about every wrong move in the sequel playbook, substituting scope and scale for the warmth and wit that made those two previous pictures so memorable."

Film Jerk: "While Spider-Man 3 is not even remotely close to the title of The Worst Movie Ever Made, it's [sic] schizophrenic pacing and apathy towards its audience's acceptance means the film never needs to be seen more than once, if that."

Rope of Silicone: "Spider-Man 3 presents a world where people come into rooms, make heartfelt speeches, and then exit for no apparent reason while the other person looks off into the distance. It's all a wacky attempt at Steel Magnolias (with webs) and it comes off as fully contrived."

Photo: Getty Images

Comments

68% at Rotten Tomatoes; you guys are picking and choosing reviewing to make a headline. Sad.

Posted by: TeddyKGB on May 3, 2007 11:44 AM

Actually, Cream of the Crop @ RT has it rated at 48% (so far). The bulk of the review authors - not to put too fine a point on it - are euphemistically referred to as "quote whores" for their willingness to give a glowing review to any movie in exchange for a bit of freebies and studio lathering.

Posted by: Marcy on May 3, 2007 3:28 PM

Advertisement


Post a comment

Your comment will not be visible for about a minute. If you don't see your comment when the page reloads, do not post it again. Reload the page in a minute, and you'll see it.

 


Something About "Gossip Girl" And Some Other Stuff

Please Say Goodbye To Momentary Staffer Moe Tkacik

P-Runway Alums Still Struggling To Make It Work

Did Matthew Broderick Cheat On Sarah Jessica Parker?

Patrick Dempsey Smells Like Avon, Has-Been Blooming

The Best Jobs Still Going To Celeb Spawn

10 C-List Celebrity Handbags

Hills House Neighbors Not Enjoying The Show

Celebrity Babies Are The Best Babies Of All!

Magazines Are All Business


EXECUTIVE EDITOR:


MANAGING EDITOR:


CONTRIBUTORS:
, , and others


Email us at:
tips@radaronline.com
or IM: TipRadar







Character Studies
10 comic book superheroes who won't be transitioning to the big screen

Head Trauma
Insiders reveal television's most hated pundits

He's Still Rock and Roll to Me
In praise of Billy Joel

Full Court Press
Charles Kaiser on "that New Yorker cover," and the rest of this week's media winners and sinners

Missing in Action
Heath Ledger's Dark Knight performance isn't Hollywood's first posthumous success





At the Movies RIP
Siskel and Ebert. Accept no substitutes

Job Interview Tips for Borderline Personalities
They really work

Bee Boys do hip-hop PSA
So worker bees think they can dance

G.W. Bush: Apology Tour '08
The president makes amends

Black, Large, and In Charge
What the funk